Aaron Schoenfeld joined Maccabi Tel Aviv and signed a 3.5-year-deal at the club. The Knoxville born striker, 193cm, began his playing career for the East Tennessee State University college, scoring 20 goals in 72 appearances. One season with Portland Phoenix attracted the attention of MLS side Columbus Crew for which he scored 5 goals in 51 appearances and 12 goals in 18 matches whilst on loan with Dayton Dutch Lions. Schoenfeld joined Maccabi Netanya in January 2016 and after two league matches was sold to Hapoel Tel Aviv where he scored 8 times in 12 league appearances. This season, Schoenfeld scored a total of 4 goals in 18 appearances in all competitions.

In the 2016/17 campaign, Schoenfeld made 12 appearances with the club, scored one goal against Beitar Jerusalem in the State Cup semifinal and assisted on two others.

The American born winger helped the Club advance to the Europa League Group Stages in the 2017/18 season and made 34 appearances (19 league) while scoring 4 goals and assisting on four others.