Shahar Piven grew up through the ranks of the Maccabi Tel Aviv Youth Department and after finishing his Under-19 career was loaned out to Beitar Tel Aviv/Ramle and Ashdod where he played in 2017/18.

 Piven returned to the club at the start of the 2018/19 season. The central defender scored his senior debut goal in the 4-1 Toto Cup victory over Hapoel Tel Aviv and made 30 appearances in all competitions before winning the championship. In 2019/20 Piven won his second championship in succession at Maccabi making 22 appearances during which he scored one league goal.